';

CASE OVERVIEW

Abdullah Haron, commonly known as Imam Haron, was a progressive Islamic scholar and imam at the Stegman Road Mosque in Cape Town. Over the years, he became increasingly critical of the government’s apartheid policies and on 28 May 1969, Haron was detained and charged with terrorism. He was kept in solitary confinement for 123 days and subjected to daily interrogations and likely torture. Haron died while in police custody on 27 September 1969. Despite evidence to the contrary, an initial inquest in 1970 ruled that Haron had fallen to his death by accident. Encouraged by the success of the Timol inquest, the Haron family has decided to request the re-opening of the inquest. However, an official decision on the matter has yet to be made by the Minister of Justice.

Imam Abdullah Haron was born in Newlands-Claremont on 8 February 1924 to Asa Martin and Amarien Haron, the youngest of five children. Having lost his mother as an infant, Haron was primarily raised by his aunt, Maryam. On 15 March 1950 Haron married Galiema Sadon. The couple had three children, Muhammed, Fatiema, and Shamela.

 

Haron was tutored in Islamic Studies by a number of eminent Islamic scholars, including Shaykh Abdurrahman al-Alawi al-Maliki, Shaykh Abdullah Taha Gamieldien, and Shaykh Ismail Ganief. The latter particularly encouraged his interest in social welfare. In addition to his religious studies, Haron also taught at a local Muslim school. Here, he befriended members of the teaching and building trade, and communist organisations. It was during this time that his political activism was awoken.

 

In 1955, at the age of 32, he was appointed to lead the Al-Jaamia congregation at the Stegman Road Mosque in Cape Town. He was one of the youngest imams in South Africa, and was considered very progressive. As imam, he worked to raise the consciousness of his congregation, and of the wider Muslim community, to the injustices of apartheid. He also forged ties with non-Muslims, including Christians, communist groups, and other faiths and organisations.

 

Over the years, he became increasingly critical of the government’s policies, and sometime in the 1950s or 1960s, he began taking part in clandestine anti-apartheid operations. In order to protect his family and congregation, he deliberately kept his political actions secret, so it is unclear exactly what operations he took part in. However, he is known to have developed close ties with the African National Congress (ANC) and the Pan Africanist Congress (PAC), both banned organisations at the time, as well as the Black Sash, a non-violent legal welfare movement of volunteer women.

 

In addition to his duties as imam, Haron also worked as a salesperson for the Wilson Rowntree confectionary company. This job allowed him legal movement in and out of black townships, despite the segregation laws that separated the races. Along with several close friends, he also established the progressive Claremont Muslim Youth Association in 1958 and a monthly newspaper, the Muslim News, in 1960. Both organisations distributed cultural, religious, and political news, and emphasised inclusivity. This ran contrary to the State’s policies of racial and religious segregation.

 

On 28 May 1969, Haron was summoned to the Security Branch office at Caledon Square in Cape Town. There, he was charged with terrorism under section 6 of the Terrorism Act 83 of 1967. The Haron family was told that he died on 27 September 1969. The police stated that he had fallen down a flight of stairs. In the aftermath of his death, his widow learnt that the Islamic marriage between her and her husband was not recognised, meaning she could not inherit his estate. As a result, Galiema Haron was forced to sell her home. At the same time, the Haron family instituted a claim against the Minister of Police and the Minister of Justice for the death in detention, but was forced to abandon the case due to financial constraints.

 

On 29 September 1969, over 40 000 people came to pay their final respects to him. A huge funeral march carried his coffin to its final resting place in Mowbray Muslim Cemetery. A few days later, on 6 October 1969, he became the first Muslim to be commemorated at St Paul’s Cathedral, where he had closely befriended Canon John Collins. Canon Collins referred to Haron as a martyr, noting his message of justice and peace that bridged racial and religious divides.

 

At the time of his death, Haron was 45. He left behind his widow, daughter Fatima Haron-Masoet (who was 5 years old when her father died), son Muhammed Haron who was 12 at the time, and a second daughter Shamila, then based in London. He was the first cleric of any faith to die in police detention in the apartheid State. His death sent shockwaves around the world, as it showed that even men of faith could be persecuted by an increasingly repressive regime.

Between 1966 and 1968, Haron is thought to have travelled in secret to Egypt to meet political exiles and the World Islamic Council. He also travelled to London, where he met with clerics of St Paul’s Cathedral, who were raising money for the families of detained or exiled political activists. Here, he struck up a deep friendship with Canon John Collins of St Paul’s, and agreed to smuggle in and distribute money raised by the cathedral to destitute families in South Africa.

 

It was during his trip abroad that Haron became aware of the increasing danger to himself and his family. His sermons and publications had caught the attention of the Security Branch of the South African Police (SAP). As a man of faith with access to a wide audience (from both within and outside of his congregation) he was considered extremely dangerous to the apartheid State.

 

On 28 May 1969, Haron was summoned to the Caledon Square Security Branch, where he was detained, interrogated, and likely tortured by various Security Branch officers, including Spyker van Wyk and Dirk Genis. Between 10 and 13 June 1969, one of Haron’s allies, Catherine Taylor of the United Party, raised the matter of his detention in Parliament. On questioning the reason behind Haron’s arrest, Taylor was told by the Minister of Police that it was ‘not in the public interest’ to reveal this information.

 

Haron was kept in solitary confinement for 123 days, and subjected to daily interrogations and likely torture. During the day, he fasted. In the evenings, Galiema Haron would visit her husband with soup for him to break his fast. However, a few days before his death, she was denied access to him. The Haron family was told that he had died on 27 September 1969. The police stated that he had fallen down a flight of stairs. His body had suffered two broken ribs, bleeding of the spine, and 27 bruises.

Due to the unnatural cause of death, an inquest was held in 1970. The inquest hearing was presided over by Magistrate JSP Kuhn. At the hearing, pathologist Dr Percy Helman testified that Haron would have been in severe pain due to his injuries, and would have been unable to move. Helman, who inspected the flight of stairs, stated that the fall could not account for all the bruises on the body. Despite this, the magistrate ruled that Haron had fallen to his death, possibly by accident. He also offered no explanation for the injuries unrelated to the fall. No one was held accountable for Haron’s death or possible torture.

The year 2019 marked the 50th anniversary of Haron’s death. On 9 September 2019, both the Stegman Road Mosque and Haron’s gravesite were declared provincial heritage sites, in honour of his memory and contributions. Encouraged by this, and the progress made on other apartheid-era cases such as the Nokuthula Simelane and Ahmed Timol cases, the Haron family has decided to request the reopening of the inquest into his death. Haron’s son, Muhammad, has stated that the family considered doing so many years ago, but had little faith that the State would take action. In the meantime, van Wyk and Genis, the two persons of material interest to the case, have died.

LATEST NEWS

TIMELINE

Timeline of events. Click the arrows to scroll.

1924
Haron is born
1950
Haron marries Galiema Sadan
1955
Haron is made an imam
1958
Haron establishes the Claremont Muslim Youth Association
1959
Haron establishes the Muslim News newspaper
1969
Haron is arrested
1969
Haron dies after 123 days in detention
1970
Inquest finds cause of death due to falling down stairs
2003
Priority Crimes Litigation Unit of NPA is created
2003
The TRC’s final report is released, stressing the need for a ‘bold prosecution policy’ in cases where amnesty has been refused
2003
The President of SA addresses Parliament on the need for criminal accountability in TRC cases
2005
NPA releases amendments to Prosecution Policy, effectively creating ‘backdoor amnesty’
2018
A selection of TRC cases, including Haron’s, are placed before the NPA for further investigation and prosecution
2019
Haron’s burial site and former mosque are declared provincial heritage sites
2019
Galiema Haron dies
2019
Haron family requests reopening of inquest

EXTRA RESOURCES

Additional material and channels

Facebook page of the Imam Haron Foundation with various resources and news
World Bulletin article, ‘The path of Imam Abdullah Haron’ (December 2013)
Press Release by the Presidency of South Africa announcing the posthumous awarding of the Order of Luthuli in Gold to Haron (April 2014)
Photograph of Advocate Howard Varney of the International Centre for Transitional Justice and other dignitaries attending the heritage declaration of Haron’s grave and former mosque (September 2019)
News 24 article, ‘Imam Haron’s grave, mosque declared Western Cape heritage sites’ (September 2019)
Mail & Guardian article, ‘Bid for slain Imam Haron’s family to see justice’ (September 2019)
IOL News article, ‘Galiema Haron, wife of apartheid martyr Imam Haron, dies’ (September 2019)
Radio 702 report, ‘Reopen inquest into Imam Haron’s death – Foundation pleads with Justice Minister’ (September 2019)
BBC News article, ‘The imam who died fighting racism in South Africa’ (October 2019)